War in the East : Supply Basics
Supply in the War in the East at first seems incredibly complicated but is actually much simpler than it seems. Though like almost everything in WitE, it’s as complicated as you choose to make it.
In Road to Minsk, a 3 turn scenario, you don’t have to worry about supply at all. You can get a decisive Axis victory without ever thinking about it. But in the other Road to scenarios, and the full campaign, it becomes much more critical. But the good news, it’s not that bad.
September 25th, 2015 edit : Click this link to open a printable PDF. Or right click and select “Save As” to put it on your computer.
The absolute basics. Keep your front line units within 5 hexes of their HQ’s. Keep the HQ as close to the railhead as possible. When you can’t do either those, airdrop supplies.
Now it’s more involved than that, but if you follow the rules above you’ll do OK in the shorter scenarios. Once winter strikes, or mud, or 1944, things become more interesting. Supply, especially for the Germans, is difficult. (As it was in reality)
Supplies are produced on the homefront and transported via rail to the front lines. Your railhead, or the furthest point that you have a rail connection to home, is the most vital point on your entire front. You may also have supply via ports, beachhead, or air, but your primary source is from the rail connection.
From the railhead supplies are sent to your HQ units. This is direct, which means it doesn’t transit through Armies to Corps. It is from HQ direct to a unit. So for example, XX Corp HQ sends supplies to the Infantry Divisions attached to it. Where the 9th Army is the HQ of XX Corp it has no relation on supply. Though any unit directly attached to the 9th Army will draw supplies from the Army Group.
Once a supply is at a railhead or friendly city/urban hex they are sent out to the HQ’s. Sometimes, if a unit can’t get supply from the HQ, they will attempt it direct. This isn’t ideal and will lead to supply loss.
From the railhead the supplies are moved by truck to the HQ, and then by truck again to the units. Your motor pool is critical in this endeavour. If you’re motor pool is low you can’t move enough supplies even though you have them at the railhead.
If you select a unit, then click on Supply Details you’ll see the screen above.
Highlighted in orange we see the Range to Rail (Hexes) and MP to Rail (Movement Points). You can do the same thing for the end combat unit.
VI Corps has a rail connection and is receiving supplies. An HQ needs to be within 25 hexes and 100 Movement Points. It will be still considered in supply if it meets MP but not hexes.
Their also must be enough Motor Pool Capacity, if there’s not then only a portion of the supply will make it to the HQ and eventually to the units.
The 6th Infantry Division is attached to VI Corps but is not within range for supply.
The end unit must be within 5 hexes or 20 Movement Points. If it’s not the unit will attempt to gain supplies from a railhead or friendly city. This isn’t ideal and leads to reduced supplies.
In the orange box we see that it’s 8 hexes to HQ, and only 14 MP’s. No good, out of HQ supply. But it is within 13 hexes to a railhead. (They follow the same rules as an HQ for distance, 25 hex / 100 MP)
In red is Phase 1 Supply, or supply from HQ. It got nothing as it didn’t meet that criteria.
In the yellow box we see Phase 2, or supply from elsewhere. The unit only received a portion of the supplies that it needs. This models the fact that trucks have to drive over horrible roads and attempt to deliver supplies. Not good.
There is a distance modifier that you see above, the further the supplies must travel, the less you get. On top of that is an Axis rail penalty that is due to the distance that goods must travel by rail. The further the rail moves east, the less efficient it becomes.
Each turn the HQ unit will gain supplies and send them out. But you can turn the HQ into a massive supply conduit, for an Admin Point cost. This will allow units in range to gain a massive supply buffer. Use this to prep motorized divisions for an assault.
The HQ will receive fuel and supplies equal to 100 times the Admin Point cost. The following turn the combat units will receive the disbursements and will be at, or near, maximum supply. They may still be fatigued though, so watch out.
This is tough on your supply network and on your Motor Pool. The further your HQ is from a railhead, the more vehicles it requires to transport. It takes the Mp to railhead * 100 vehicles from your motor. Of that count, 10% are considered destroyed. If you’re 50 MP from the railhead it’ll take 5,000 vehicles, 500 of which are considered gone.
For short games you probably won’t pay much attention to the motor pool, but in long games it is critical. You’ll see expert players watch this closely, I’ve read a few AAR’s where they called it in late 1943 because the Motor Pool was so low that the Axis player knew he didn’t have a chance to recover.
Other Supply Methods
You can use Air Transport Mode (F9) to attempt a supply delivery by air. Just right click on the target and the aircraft will drop supplies. It likely won’t be enough to bring a Panzer Division to 100%, but it might be enough to squeeze out just a bit more.
You’ll also have beachhead mode which allows supplies to be transferred via water. This only works if you have a friendly port on that body of water. Note that it isn’t as efficient as rail transport.
Panzer Example
It’s likely the first time you research Supply will be when your Panzer Divisions suddenly run out of fuel.
In our example we’ll be at the very end of the supply chain, 24 hexes and 99 Movement Points from the railhead. Our HQ is following just behind the Panzer Divisions. We’ll assume a full motor pool.
So right off the bat we have 25 divided by 99 MP, to give us a modifier of 25% due to MP. Then we have a 10 divided by 24 Hex, to give us a modifier of 41%.
With ideal supply, only 25% gets through due to the Movement Points. Of that 25%, we can reduce it again by 41%.
We end up getting just 10% of our needed supplies at the end of that stretched out supply chain.
Moving your railhead is essential, and is the major limiting factor in your advance. Use your FBD units to repair and convert the rail lines as quickly as possible. They make pretty good time until they get through the Baltic Rail Zone. After that it costs 3 points to repair the rails instead of 1.
While it can be daunting Supply isn’t terribly difficult. There are other instances and cases related to supply but what you see here will keep you rolling. The system does a pretty good job modelling the difficulties that the Wehrmacht faced during Barbarossa. How you handle that situation is one of the interesting nuances to War in the East.
Loulou
Excellent, thank you for this article.
Barry
Thanks Casey,
A nice summary of some basic rules – they pointed out a few things that i knew about from the rules but hadn’t really worked out yet how (or why) they were important – nor how to use them effectively. You have been a big help!
Cheers
Barry
Alan
Succinct, clear summary! Using your Army/Panzer Group airbases to receive air supply also helps keep extended lines working better.
ChuckB
Casey – thanks a lot for this great series, really helpful! One question about your explanation with the 6th Infantry Division: Under your screen with the “supply detail” of this unit you state “The end unit must be within 5 hexes or 20 Movement Points” and in the next paragraph you write “In the orange box we see that it’s 8 hexes to HQ, and only 14 MP’s. No good, out of HQ supply.”
It appears that the rule is probably 5 hexes AND 20 Movement Points instead of or, otherwise 8 hexes/14MPs should suffice, is that correct? Above this screen you lay out the rules for HQs and there is does say “and” instead of “or”.
Thanks a lo!
ChuckB
Casey
Hi Chuck,
You are correct, good catch! One case where you’ll see this is if a unit is across a river, and during mud, it might only be three hexes, but 25 MP’s.
I hope I’ve explained it properly for you, I can’t check the manual right now.
Thanks Chuck!
ChuckB
Hi Casey – yes, your explanation (especially combined with the screens) for all the different elements are really helpful! Still working my way into the game and making progress …
I saw that you also use Jison’s great map & unit mod; in case you’re interested, I modded it a while ago for myself to reinstate the soft factor corners and the movement indicators (which I liked better with the original units) – here’s a link to my forum posting http://www.matrixgames.com/forums/fb.asp?m=3782399
Happy to share, if you’re interested
Chuck
Casey
That’s awesome, thank you!
I much preferred the original color soft factor than the black tick marks.
Pingback: War in the East : Supply Basics - Casey Calouette